Getting crushed by SonarQube

I have been upgrading our Sonar server from 4.5 to 4.5.2 and restructuring our project. I initially was planning on upgrading to SonarQube 5.0, but the upgrade process can’t seem to handle our database. After I upgraded to 4.5.2, I was restructuring. Initially we had each of our libraries setup as a separate project at work and there was a separate sonar project for each one. At one point we decided it was much better to consolidate them all under 1 git repository and make 1 maven master pom with each other project as a module in maven. When we did that we never got around to consolidating our Sonar project to 1 project with sub projects. After we upgraded to intelliJ we found that we couldn’t sue the sonar plugins to integrate with our environment as our project didn’t match our sonar project.

Hence I started working on restructuring it to reflect our current project structure. Of course me being me the first thing I want to do is update to the latest. After the Database Schema Upgrade to version 5.0 failed I restored from a previous backup and then did the upgrade to 4.5.2. After upgrading I also had to upgrade many of our plugins. Upon completion of that I ran the analysis and started working on fixing the new errors. I was getting pretty close to having all the issues fixed when I discovered many of the rules we were using were deprecated. We had 99 deprecated rules plugins so I disabled them and enabled the suggested replacements. Oh what a mistake, after being down to about 60 issues to fix that put me up to 1000. Ay!!! At the end we will have much better rules in place for our code, but after working on it all day today and not quite resolving all the issues I am sort of kicking myself for upgrading too much at once. Oh well I guess in the end it will be worth the pain.

Code Coverage

In my current position one of the metrics we track is code coverage for our unit tests. When I started at the company we were using JUnit with Mockito and JaCoCo. This was a pretty good setup we got good coverage reports and Mockito makes the testing writing much easier.

One of the limitations of Mockito is that you can’t mock private methods or static methods. This presented an issue for us in reaching our desired level of coverage. We initially worked around some of the private method issues using reflection, but it wasn’t always ideal. The decision was made to use PowerMock. PowerMock solved all of our Mockito issues immediately. It was compatible with Mockito but gave us some new powerful features to allow us to get much better unit test coverage. Then we ran our Jacoco reports and found that the reporting no longer worked. Due to the way PowerMock uses byte code manipulation in order to mock static methods it is not compatible with JaCoCo and there is no plan for them to support measuring that.

So we figured no big deal and switched to Cobertura. The first problem with this change is that Cobertura 2.0.3 has a regression in it so it won’t report coverage with Powermock. We figured no big deal we will run the 1.9.4.1 release of it until they release a bug fix so we can update. Unfortunately the update has never come. You go to the roadmap for the site and you see it hasn’t been updated since November 7, 2013. There appears to be very little activity on the project, and we haven’t seen an update in 2 years. I see work going on in the github repository but there seems to be no attempt and doing any maintenance or fixing the issues for the existing users, and I can’t get a feel for when the 2.1 release is ever going to come out. A second issue is that the current version doesn’t support Java 8 and I would like to update to Java 8 in the very near future. At what point when dealing with open source software do you say the project is either dead or too inactive for us to rely on for business needs?

Cut to last week I was updating some libraries in the project and I wanted to upgrade from PowerMock 1.5.5 to PowerMock 1.6.1 and my coverage reports went to 0. So it seems our old version of Cobertura can’t handle the latest PowerMock. I did a test with Atlassian Clover and our coverage reports worked perfect and looked better than anything I have ever seen for a report. At that point I decided I had reached my breaking point with Cobertura and put in a request that we move to clover and buy some server licenses and work and in the meantime while waiting for approval I had to settle for PowerMock 1.5.6 until we can get approval to buy Clover licenses.

Going forward when someone suggests a new tool to fix an issue that we are having, I have to say that I am going to be looking into other things that tool drags along with it as I don’t want to be in the situation again where we are trading one problem for another.

Themes for 2015

As my Christmas vacation draws to a close I am starting to think of themes for 2015. Why themes and not goals or resolutions? Well I think resolutions are sort of setting yourself up for failure and goals are very rigid so I am going with more general themes.

  • Obviously the first theme I am working towards will be updating this site at least once a week ideally with something technical that I have learned during the week or thoughts on a problem I am solving.
  • Next on the agenda I would like to try to read more. I haven’t been reading as many books as I like to during 2014. But at the end of the year I have been picking up the pace a bit so I hope to read at least 2 books a month. My system I have been using is to try to get through 10% of a book a day on my kindle.
  • I would like to spend more time doing stuff in Spring Boot this year. I have been reading Greg Turnquist’s Learning Spring Boot and it is a great book which I strongly recommend. He seems to lay out the information right when I want it in the book and has saved me tons of time that I would have spent digging in the docs for answers otherwise.
  • Anyone who knows me know that I am not a big front end person, but as a full stack developer I need to know all the layers of the stack, so I think 2015 is the year that I need to learn Angular JS. I learned Knockout JS in 2014 and appreciated how much more productive it was for things than just jQuery and it seems to me that the market is all going Angular and people say it is more productive than knockout so it is time to give it a try.
  • I am hoping to do some architectural updates at work. I am ready to get our stack upgraded (I want to be on Spring 4.1 and Java 8 at a minimum and ideally JPA 2.1 as well instead of 2.0). I always prefer to run the latest stuff so I will be working hard to make sure that I can do so. On that note I submitted a Jira for the issue holding me back on Spring 4.1 related to the aspectj-maven-plugin. With any luck I will be on Spring 4.1 at work within the next 2-3 weeks. Java 8 may take a bit longer as it is going to mean a container upgrade.

Anyway that is what I have come up with so far I am sure more things will apply as time goes on, but this is a good start to my year plan. Now to enjoy my final 2 days of vacation before I return to work.